Tuesday, October 28, 2008

What is your plan?

The economy is going down the drains, oil prices are also coming down. Does this mean the end for alternative energy? Are people going to be so submerged in survival mode that they will forget what got them there in the first place? Perhaps.

I do believe in the next 5 years we will see fundamental changes in the way we live. I am not sure what those changes will be, I have a feeling the transition is going to be a painful one. The market values will shift from the more superfluous goods and services (i.e. electronic gadgets and fashion) to others more basic ones (i.e. food and energy).

So, if energy becomes a more precious good then we will certainly shift into renewable energy, right? Not so fast, there is a "Tipping Point" to make the shift from fossil fuels into alternative energy, and the odds are against us.

When resources are scarce it is more difficult to decide on a strategy that requires an up front payment even if this strategy is more convenient over time.

If you offer two plans for certain service: plan "A" consist of monthly payments of $10 (for one year total $120); under plan "B" you just make a single $102 payment at the beginning of the year (a 15% discount!). I am sure people with fewer resources will select the monthly plan more times than the "B" plan, simply because it is easier to deliver $10 each month that it is to come up with the full $102. Only if you have the $102 easily available and you are smart enough to calculate the 15% difference (which is more than what most investments return on capital in today's market!), then you will chose plan "B".

Alternative energy requires an up front "investment" to develop new technology, to create new infrastructure and to change certain patterns in the market and in consumer behavior. The current oil thirsty system needs no change in the short term, only when oil becomes scarce enough, then we shall see the high cost of staying in this path. Its like having plan "A" with the last month's payment at $200 (rather than $10) and no right to renew!

For the time being the oil barrel has dropped from the $140 level to the $60 level. Oil, as any other product, follows the laws of supply and demand (as demand dwindles, the price drops). What some people don't realize is that supply and demand work for infinite availability products (subject to cost of production), oil has a very clear limit (when the end of oil is near, even if demand is low, prices will soar). Another peculiarity about oil is that, as the price decreases, oil supply decreases as well. Some sources of oil are too expensive to operate at $50 a barrel. This works against the cause for alternatives, as the supply diminishes, new sources become cost effective and reduce the impact of the diminishing supply.

What shall we do (we = humanity)??. We should have a plan!

Only by having a plan we can counter the INERTIA of the masses (and right now the inertia points towards more oil dependency).

Mr. T. Boone Pickens has a plan (recently featured in CBS's "60 minutes"), to generate wind power and use natural gas for vehicles (for pros and cons on The Pickens Plan go to Wind Energy).

In Israel and now in Australia, Shai Agassi has a plan to deliver electric cars, coordinating between government, car manufacturers, battery manufacturers and creating a "plug in" infrastructure (for more on this go to The Electric Car).

My plan is to find investment opportunities in Greentech. Opportunities with the best technology, the best management and the best business plan I can find. And hope they will make it big and create a better environment and at the same time give me a hefty return on my investment.

What is your plan?!

Until next week, SHALOM!

4 comments:

Witmake said...

This article is good.
I agree to your opinions.
There is a long way to run.
Forgive my English, I am from China and English is not my native language.

We must prepare for the future. Oil is limited, coal is limited. In china a great amount is generated by coal, and the steel groups have great consumptions, too. I am worried that one day in a sudden the coal and oil disappeared and people are still not prepared.

TheGreenNova said...

My greatest fear is that as prices at the pump ease, folks will so easily (again) forget the pain of the price only a few months ago.

Reading the prior comment, between the lines it seems in China more fear exists over the depletion of coal supply than oil. No words about clean coal tech, which is an awesome venue in the western world. I hope they are also becoming as concerned about emissions, as supply.

We have a plan to inspire, promote, motivate and support the development of energy solutions.
Please take a look at TheGreenNova. org and survey the site via the survey monkey button on the right panel.
TheGreenNova is a new nonprofit organization and the site is brand new, but live. It is intended as a wiki forum resource center to provide design, development and product launch tools not commonly individuals and small business. Thanks, Mark
MGA@ TheGreenNova. org

Unknown said...

Hi Sami,

I have a plan even in these current tough economic times. I'm a developer of solar thermal projects that are commercially viable even with oil at $50. These projects will appeal to the type of investor you describe (understands the value of putting up capital backed by long term purchase agreements that offer double digit IRR's. If you are such an investor, I would be happy to discuss details with you.
Best regards,
Daniel Schwab
MD Kayema Energy Solutions (Pty) Ltd.
skype "schwabmd"
mobile: +27 72 3344 308

Sami Shiro said...

A comment from my LinkedIn network:
On 10/29/08 4:51 AM, Ann Grackin wrote:
--------------------
Alternative energy industry, like all emerging industries, has fundamental challenges that need to be overcome in order for the 'switching cost' to be a no-brainer.
Here are some important issues to consider:
1. Cost of solar is coming down.
2. Cost of oil will go up. (We are dealing with a shortage after all--also this time of year, historically oil is in lower demand and will go back up.)
3. Other energy sources are also in abundant supply. Wind, etc, so they are worth developing (and are by many nations).
4. Most nations need to reduce their dependency--for political, not just economic reasons--on Middle East oil. The cost to western societies of the war on 'terror' is too costly and will need other times of remedies.
5. Even with 'drill baby drill' as President, the reality is that we may not know exactly where to drill and will be on a waiting list--for many years--for the needed capital and equipment to build these new sites.
6. Economically, most emerging tech companies have big challenges ahead--technology, supply chain, project management, etc; but there are winner s who are getting their prices down. However the path to coming online has many factors that have to be addressed in the market place. These issues are more of a factor that the variable price of oil.

There are a whole bunch of philosophic and politic points of view that could be discussed, but I will avoid these and just stick with economic and supply chain realities.

Your question is good and is worthy of a whole 'workshop' of energy economics. AG